Circular definitions
Circular definitions are considered ineffective because they fail to provide any new information or clarity. A circular definition is one in which the term being defined is used within the definition itself, creating a loop that doesn't add any understanding of the term. For instance, "A woman is a person who identifies as one" is a circular definition because it defines "woman" using the term "identifies as one," which doesn't provide any new information.
Circular definitions can cause confusion and misunderstandings, as they don't add to the understanding of the term being defined. Additionally, they can't be used to prove or disprove any statement as they don't provide any new information. In contrast, a good definition should provide a clear and accurate understanding of the term, be consistent with other definitions and usage within the field, and not be circular.
Having clear and universally accepted definitions in science is crucial because it helps to ensure consistent and accurate communication between researchers and practitioners. It promotes the reproducibility of findings, allows for comparability of results across studies and disciplines, and facilitates the advancement of knowledge and understanding in the field. Furthermore, unambiguous definitions are essential in the design and interpretation of experiments, and the development of new theories and hypotheses.
Proper terminology is important in activism and human rights protection because it guarantees clear and accurate communication about the issues being addressed. This builds a shared understanding and promotes effective advocacy, challenges harmful stereotypes and misconceptions, and helps to hold individuals and institutions accountable for their actions. Clear definitions also ensure that the rights of women are respected and protected.
Having distinct words to denote female humans (one for adult, another for minor), promotes equality and highlights the unique experiences and issues we face. It also creates a shared language for activism and policy-making related to women's rights. Clear, inclusive, and non-discriminatory language is crucial in promoting and protecting these rights.
https://womensdeclaration.com/
Expanding the definition of a word to include elements outside of its original definition dilutes and distorts its meaning, making it less precise and less effective for communication. Words are meant to convey specific ideas and concepts, and expanding their definition reduces their specificity and accuracy in communicating the intended meaning. This results in misunderstandings, misinterpretations, and confusion, especially in fields such as science, law, and activism where precise language is critical. By maintaining clear and distinct definitions for words, we can ensure that communication remains effective and that each word accurately conveys its intended meaning.